Sigrún Davíðsdóttir's Icelog

Easing capital controls: Non-negotiable terms and national interests

with 6 comments

In a heavily staged appearance, prime minister Sigmundur Davíð Gunnlaugsson told Icelanders that ISK850bn, ca 45% of Icelandic GDP would fall into the state coffers, used to reduce the public debt, not for pet projects as earlier announced. With

The size of the problem to solve amounts to ISK1200bn, i.e. this is the sum of ISK, in the estates of the banks and Glacier bonds etc., that cannot be converted to FX and therefore cannot be paid out to creditors right now. What amounts to ISK850bn, or 39% of the assets of the estates at the end of this year will have to be paid off in a stability “contribution” if composition is negotiated and then this amount will be reduced – or tax and bankruptcy if no composition, to fulfil what the government calls “stability conditions.”

Glacier bond-holders and others will either be able to take part in auctions in autumn or buy long-term bonds. All of this is done under the auspice of a phrase repeated over and over again: “National interests takes precedence over interests of private parties.” Here is the English press release, carefully worded and not very clear.

After dealing with this amount, pension funds and ordinary Icelanders will have greater movement. Some quick thoughts on some of the topics du jour:

Size of the problem:

It is clear that the ISK300bn (actually ISK290bn) of the remains of the old overhang (see my last blog before this one on the barest essentials) cannot be paid out in FX – so this amount is clearly a part of the problem. But this is already being dealt with and that action will now continue: the CBI will hold auctions in autumn and those ISK-owners can also buy long-term bonds to come, either in ISK of FX.

That leaves ISK900bn – and this is a more questionable size: ISK500bn (ISK507bn exactly) is the number I have been posting earlier as the size of the problem because these are ISK assets. The remaining ISK400bn are FX assets in Iceland, i.e. assets in Iceland paid off in FX, which I would think was a more debatable size but this is how the government defines the size of the problem.

Stability “conditions” – contributions and tax:

So the problem that needs to be solved amounts to ISK1200 – and by reducing it by 39% the rest can be paid out. Or that seems to be the calculation.

The conditions, i.e. the numbers, are non-negotiable, as was repeated again and again. If the estates negotiate a composition by the end of the year they do not pay a tax but a “contribution”: in fact the same numbers, i.e. 39% or ISK850 but – as far as I understand this will be some reduction so the amount will be ISK500-600bn.

If they do not negotiate a composition the estates go into bankruptcy and pay the full amount: 39%.

This leaves some angles since the ISK850 is well above the ISK500bn but not quite the ISK900bn and well, the ISK300bn is outside of this equation. How these numbers were found I do not know but well, this is how the non-negotiable numbers look like.

The non-mentioned dates

Apart from foreign creditors smarting from controls there are the Icelanders: here, pension funds will be able to invest for ISK10bn a year, more or less what they have asked for, until 2020, unclear from when. And ordinary people will at some non-mentioned date be able to feel liberalisation on certain transactions.

What will creditors do?

Some creditors have already been negotiating with representatives of the government so the plan is indeed not quite out of the blue. According to a Glitnir announcement today, 25% of their creditors agree to this.

Kaupthing’s situation is different, less ISK assets, which might mean that Kaupthing creditors will be less happy to pay. However, no chance to tell until there is an announcement. Everyone might be happy to see an end to this and possible payout in sight.

Either this will all go well, composition beckon and much good will. Or not and the future is legal wrangling in multiple jurisdictions for a decade, like in Argentina. Today, the Icelandic government has taken the country on a journey along a very narrow road above a precipice. If all goes well, everyone reaches the final destination on the other side and there will be much rejoice.

 

Follow me on Twitter for running updates.

Written by Sigrún Davídsdóttir

June 8th, 2015 at 3:26 pm

Posted in Uncategorised

6 Responses to 'Easing capital controls: Non-negotiable terms and national interests'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Easing capital controls: Non-negotiable terms and national interests'.

  1. Kaupthing announcement now posted here: http://www.kaupthing.com/home/announcements/all-announcements/2015/06/08/Kaupthing-hf-Response-to-the-Announcement-from-the-Government-Regarding-Capital-Control-Liberalization/

    with link to Finance Ministry announcement on consultations with affected parties.

    anrigaut

    8 Jun 15 at 10:55 pm

  2. […] already explained, I doubt the size of the problem as related to the estates: I estimate it being ISK500bn, not […]

  3. It抯 onerous to find educated folks on this subject, however you sound like you recognize what you抮e speaking about! Thanks

    off white hoodie

    19 Oct 23 at 10:28 pm

  4. I am glad for writing to let you know what a fantastic experience my wife’s child gained checking your web page. She came to find a good number of things, which include what it is like to have an awesome coaching character to have other people effortlessly comprehend some multifaceted subject areas. You undoubtedly exceeded my desires. Thanks for offering those insightful, healthy, educational as well as unique thoughts on this topic to Janet.

    jordan shoes

    19 Dec 23 at 12:48 pm

  5. Thanks so much for giving everyone an extremely special opportunity to read from this website. It is often very pleasurable plus full of a lot of fun for me and my office peers to search your website at the least 3 times a week to read through the fresh items you have got. And of course, I’m just at all times fulfilled with all the excellent advice you serve. Some 3 facts in this post are certainly the most effective I have ever had.

    birkin bag

    21 Jan 24 at 9:46 am

  6. I wanted to draft you a very small word so as to thank you very much once again on the marvelous ideas you have contributed at this time. It has been quite remarkably generous with people like you to deliver freely what a lot of folks would have made available as an e-book to earn some dough for their own end, especially considering that you could have tried it in case you considered necessary. These basics as well served to become easy way to realize that many people have the same fervor the same as my very own to understand great deal more regarding this problem. Certainly there are numerous more pleasurable sessions ahead for many who see your site.

    goyard

    22 Jan 24 at 1:04 pm

Leave a Reply