This time, no different from earlier: FX risk hidden from borrowers
The Swiss Franc unpegging from the euro 15 January this year brought the risk of foreign currency borrowing for unhedged borrowers yet again to the fore. In Central, Eastern and South-Eastern Europe lending in Swiss Franc and other foreign currency, most notably in euros, has been common since the early 2000s, often amounting to more than half of loans issued to households. The 2008 crisis put some damper on this lending, did not stop it though and in addition legacy issues remain. Now, actions by foreign currency borrowers in various countries are also unveiling a less glorious aspect: mis-selling and breach of European Directives on consumer protection. Senior bankers involved in foreign currency lending invariably claim that banks could not possibly foresee FX fluctuation. Yet, all of this has happened earlier in different parts of the world, most notably in Australia in the 1980s.
“The 2008-09 financial crisis has highlighted the problems associated with currency mismatches in the balance sheets of emerging market borrowers, particularly in Emerging Europe,” economists at the European Bank of Reconstruction and Development, EBRD, Jeromin Zettelmeyer, Piroska Nagy and Stephen Jeffrey wrote in the summer of 2009.*
In the grand scheme of Western and Northern European countries this mismatch was a little-noticed side-effect of the 2008 crisis. But at the EBRD, focused on Central, Eastern, South East European, CESEE, countries, its chief economist Erik Berglöf and his colleagues worried since foreign currency, FX, lending was common in this part of Europe. FX lending per se was not the problem but the fact that these loans were to a great extent issued to unhedged borrowers, i.e. borrowers who have neither assets nor income in FX. This lending was also partly the focus of the Vienna Initiative, launched in January 2009 by the EBRD, European and international organisations and banks to help resolve problems arising from CESEE countries mainly being served by foreign banks.
In Iceland FX lending took off from 2003 following the privatisation of the banks: with the banks growing far beyond the funding capacity of Icelandic depositors, foreign funding poured in to finance the banks’ expansion abroad. Icelandic interest rates were high and the rates of euro, Swiss Franc, CHF and yen attractive. Less so in October 2008 when the banks had collapsed: at the end of October 2007 1 euro stood at ISK85, a year later at ISK150 and by October 2009 at ISK185.
After Icelandic borrowers sued one of the banks, the Supreme Court ruled in a 2010 judgement that FX loans were indeed legal but not FX indexed loans, which most of household loans were. It took further time and several judgements to determine the course of action: household loans were recalculated in ISK at the very favourable foreign interest rates. Court cases are still on-going, now to test FX lending against European directives on consumer-protection.
In all these stories of FX loans turning into a millstone around the neck of borrowers in various European countries senior bankers invariably say the same thing: “we couldn’t possibly foresee the currency fluctuations!” In a narrow sense this is true: it is not easy to foresee when exactly a currency fluctuation will happen. Yet, these fluctuation are frequent; consequently, if a loan has a maturity of more than just a few years it is as sure as the earth revolving around the sun that a fluctuation of ca. 20%, often considerably more, will happen.
Interestingly, many of the banks issuing FX loans in emerging Europe did indeed make provisions for the risk, only not on behalf of their clients. According to economist at the Swiss National Bank, SNB, Pinar Yeşin “banks in Europe have continuously held more foreign-currency-denominated assets than liabilities, indicating their awareness of the exchange-rate-induced credit risk they face.”
Indeed, many of the banks lending to unhedged borrowers took measures to hedge themselves. Understandably so since it has all happened before. Recent stories of FX lending misery in various European countries are nothing but a rerun of what happened in many countries all over the world in earlier decades: i.a., events in Australia in the 1980s are like a blueprint of the European events. In Australia leaked documents unveiled that senior bankers knew full well of the risk to unhedged borrowers but they kept it to themselves.
It can also be argued that given certain conditions FX lending led to systematic lending to CESEE clients borrowing more than they would have coped with in domestic currency making FX lending a type of sub-prime lending. What now seems clear is that cases of mis-selling, unclear fees and insufficient documentation now seem to be emerging, albeit slowly, in European FX lending to unhedged borrowers.
FX lending in CESEE: to what extent and why
A striking snapshot of lending in Emerging Europe is that “local currency finance comes second,” with the exception of the Czech Republic and Poland, as Piroska Nagy pointed out in October 2010, referring to EBRD research. With under-developed financial markets in these countries banking systems there are largely dominated by foreign banks or subsidiaries of foreign banks.
This also means, as Nagy underlined, that there is an urgent need to reduce “systemic risks associated with FX lending to unhedged borrowers” as this would remove key vulnerabilities and “enhance monetary policy effectiveness.”
Although action has been taken in some of the European countries hit by FX lending, “legacy” issues remain, i.e. problems stemming from prolific FX lending in the years up to 2008 and even later. In short, FX lending is still a problem to many households and a threat to European banks, in addition to non-performing loans, i.e. loans in arrears, arising from unhedged FX lending.
The most striking mismatch in terms of banks’ behaviour is evident in the operations of the Austrian banks that have been lending in FX at home in Austria the euro country, but also abroad in the neighbouring CESEE countries. In Austria, FX loans were available to wealthy individuals who mostly hedged their FX balloon loans (i.e. a type of “interest only” loans) with insurance of some sort. Abroad however, “these loans in most cases had not been granted mostly to relatively high income households,” as somewhat euphemistically stated in the Financial Stability report by the Austrian Central Bank, OeNB in 2009.
There is plenty of anecdotal evidence to conclude that during the boom years banks were pushing FX loans to borrowers, rather than the other way around. Thus, it can be concluded that the FX lending in CESEE countries was a form of sub-prime lending, that is people who did not meet the requirements for borrowing in the domestic currency could borrow, or borrow more, in FX. This would then also explain why FX loans to unhedged borrowers did become such a major problem in these countries.
Where these loans have become a political issue FX borrowers have often been met with allegations of greed; that they were trying to gain by gambling on the FX market. In 2010 Martin Brown, economist at the SNB and two other economists published a study on “Foreign Currency Loans – Demand or Supply Driven?” They attempted to answer the question by studying loans to Bulgarian companies 2003-2007. What they discovered was i.a. that for 32% of the FX business loans issued in their sample the companies had indeed asked for local currency loan.
“Our analysis suggests that the bank lends in foreign currency, not only to less risky firms, but also when the firm requests a long-term loan and when the bank itself has more funding in euro. These results imply that foreign currency borrowing in Eastern Europe is not only driven by borrowers who try to benefit from lower interest rates but also by banks hesitant to lend long-term in local currency and eager to match the currency structure of their assets and liabilities.”
In other words, the banks had more funding in euro than in the local currency and consequently, by lending in FX (here, euro), the banks were hedging themselves in addition to distancing themselves from instable domestic conditions. A further support for this theory is FX lending in Iceland, which took off when the banks started to seek funding on international markets. (The effect on banks’ FX funding is not uncontested: further on reasons for FX lending in Europe see EBRD’s “Transition Report” 2010, Ch. 3, esp. Box 3.2.)
The Australian lesson: with clear information “…nobody in their right mind… would have gone ahead with it”
Financial deregulation began in Australia in the early 1970s. Against that background, the Australian dollar was floated in December 1983. In the years up to 1985 banks in Australia had been lending in FX, often to farmers who previously had little recourse to bank credit. However, the Australian dollar started falling in early 1985; from end of 1984 to the lowest point in July 1986 the trade-weighted index depreciated by more then a third. Consequently, the FX loans became too heavy a burden for many of the burrowers, with the usual ensuing misery: bankruptcy, loss of homes, breaking up of marriages and, in the most tragic cases, suicide.
The Australian bankers shrugged their shoulders; it had all been unforeseeable. FX borrowers who tried suing the banks lost miserably in court, unable to prove that bankers had told them the currency fluctuations would never be that severe and if it did the bank would intervene. As one judge put it: “A foreign borrowing is not itself dangerous merely because opportunities for profit, or loss, may exist.” The prevailing understanding in the justice system was that those borrowing in FX had willingly taken on a gamble where some lose, some win.
But gambling turned out to be a mistaken parallel: a gambler knows he is gambling; the FX borrowers did not know they were involved in FX gambling. The borrowers got organised, by 1989 they had formed the Foreign Currency Borrowers Association and assisted in suing the banks. The tide finally turned in favour of the borrowers and against the banks; the courts realised that unlike gamblers the borrowers had been wholly unaware of the risk because the banks had not done their duty in properly informing the FX borrowers of the risk. But by this time FX borrowers had already been suffering pain and misery for four to five years.
What changed the situation were internal documents, two letters, tabled on the first day of a case against one of the banks, Westpac. The letters, provided by a Westpac whistle-blower, John McLennan, showed that when the loan in question was issued in March 1985 the Westpac management was already well aware of the risk but said nothing to clients. Staff dealing with clients was often ignorant of the risks and did not fully understand the products they were welling. When it transpired who had provided the documents Westpac sued McLennan – a classic example of harassment whistle-blowers almost invariably suffer – but later settled with McLennan.
As a former senior manager summed it up in 1991: “Let us face it – nobody in their right mind, if they had done a proper analysis of what could happen, would have gone ahead with it.” (See here for an overview of some Australian court cases regarding FX loans).
FX borrowers of all lands, unify!
“Probably like a lot of other people (.) I felt that the banks knew what they were doing, and you know, that they could be trusted in giving you the right advice,” is how one Westpac borrower summed it up in a 1989 documentary on the Australian FX lending saga.
This misplaced trust in banks delayed action against the banks in Australia in the 1980s and in all similar sagas. However, at some point bank clients realise the banks take their care of duty towards clients lightly but are better at safeguarding own interests. As in Australia, the most effective way is setting up an association to fight the banks in a more targeted cost-efficient way.
This has now happened in many European countries hit by FX loans and devaluation. At a conference in Cyprus in early December, organised by a Cypriot solicitor Katherine Alexander-Theodotou, representatives from fifteen countries gathered to share experience and inform of state of affairs and actions taken in their countries regarding FX loans. This group is now working as an umbrella organization at a European level, has a website and aims i.a. at influencing consumer protection at European level.
Spain is part of the euro zone and yet banks in Spain have been selling FX loans. Patricia Suárez Ramírez is the president of Asuapedefin, a Spanish association of FX borrowers set up in 2009. She says that since the Swiss unpegging in January the number of Asuapedefin members has doubled. “There is an information mismatch between the banks and their clients. Given the full information, nobody in their right mind would invest all their assets in foreign currency and guarantee with their home. Banks have access to forecasts like Bloomberg and knew from early 2007 that the euro would devalue against the Swiss Franc and Japanese Yen.”
As in Australia, the first cases in most of the European countries have in general and for various reasons not been successful: judges have often not been experienced enough in financial matters; as in Australia clients lack evidence; there tends to be a bias favouring the banks and so far, only few cases have reached higher instances of the courts. However, in Europe the tide might be turning in favour of FX borrowers, thanks to an fervent Hungarian FX borrower.
The case of Árpád Kásler and the European Court of Justice
In April 2014 the European Court of Justice, ECJ, ruled on a Hungarian case, referred to it by a Hungarian Court: Árpád Kásler and his wife v OTP Jelzálogbank, ECJ C‑26/13. The Káslers had contested the bank’s charging structure, which they claimed unduly favoured the bank and also claimed the loan contract had not been clear: the contract authorised the bank to calculate the monthly instalment on the basis of the selling rate of the CHF, on which the loan was based, whereas the amount of the loan advanced was determined by the bank on the basis of the buying rate of the CHF.
After winning their case the bank appealed the judgement after which the Hungarian Court requested a preliminary ruling from the ECJ, concerning “the interpretation of Articles 4(2) and 6(1) of Council Directive 93/13/EEC of 5 April 1993 on unfair terms in consumer contracts (OJ 1993 L 95, p. 29, ‘the Directive’ or ‘Directive 93/13’).”
In its judgment the ECJ partly sided with the Káslers. It ruled that the fee structure was unjust: the bank did not, as it claimed, incur any service costs as the loan was indeed only indexed to CHF; the bank did not actually go into the market to buy CHF. The Court also ruled that it was not enough that the contract was “grammatically intelligible to the consumer” but should also be set out in such a way “that consumer is in a position to evaluate… the economic consequences” of the contract for him. Regarding the third question – what should substitute the contract if it was deemed unfair – the ECJ left it to the national court to decide on the substitute.
Following the ECJ judgement in April 2014, the Hungarian Supreme Court ruled in favour of the Káslers: the fee structure had indeed favoured the bank and was not fair, the contract was not clear enough and the loan should be linked to interest rates set by the Hungarian Central Bank. – As in the Australian cases Kásler’s fight had taken years and come at immense personal pain and pecuniary cost.
Hungarian law are not precedent-based, which meant that the effect on other similar loan contracts was not evident. In July 2014 the Hungarian Parliament decided that banks lending in FX should return the fee that the Kásler judgement had deemed unfair.
The European Banking Authority, EBS is the new European regulator. The ECJ ruling in many ways reflects what the EBA has been pointing from the time it was set up in 2011. In its advice in 2013 on good practice for responsible mortgage lending it emphasises “a comprehensive disclosure approach in foreign currency lending, for example using scenarios to illustrate the effect of interest and exchange rate movements.”
Calculated gamble v being blind-folded at the gambling table
“Since the ECJ judgment in the Kásler case, judges in Spain have started to agree with consumers from banks,” says Patricia Suárez Ramírez. So far, anecdotal evidence supports her view that the ECJ judgment in the Kásler case is, albeit slowly, determining the course of other similar cases in other EU countries.
The FX loans were clearly a risk to unhedged borrowers in the countries where these loans were prevalent. If judgements to come will be in favour of borrowers, as in ECJ C‑26/13, the banks clearly face losses: in some cases even considerable losses if the FX loans will have to be recalculated on an extensive scale, as did indeed happen in Iceland.
Voices from the financial sector are already pointing out the unfairness of demands that the banks recalculate FX loans or compensate unhedged FX borrowers. However, it seems clear that banks took a calculated gamble on FX lending to unhedged borrowers. In the best spirit of capitalism, you win some you lose some. The unfairness here does not apply to the banks but to their unhedged clients, who believed in the banks’ duty of care and who, instead of being sold a sound product, were led blind-folded to the gambling table.
*The first draft was written in July 2009; published 2010 as EBRD Working Paper.
This is the first article in a series on FX lending in Europe: the unobserved threat to FX unhedged borrowers – and European banks.The next article will be on Austrian banks, prolific FX lenders both at home and abroad, though with an intriguing difference. The series is cross-posted on Fistful of Euros.
See here an earlier article of mine on FX lending, cross-posted on Fistful of Euros and my own blog, Icelog.
Follow me on Twitter for running updates.
hi!,I love your writing very a lot! share we communicate
more about your post on AOL? I need a specialist on this house to resolve my
problem. Maybe that’s you! Having a look ahead to look you.
cuevana2espanol
4 Sep 19 at 9:45 pm
An experienced contractor is the best choice for a concrete job.
Concrete is today the most frequently used, man manufactured material throughout the world.
Concrete was first developed by the Romans. It is composed up of cement, limestone gravel, sand, and aggregate.
When mixed with water, concrete can be poured in molds to
create pre-determined designs, which is vital and beneficial to
create innovative yet simple construction. Concrete mixes require precision and knowledge about
the correct ratios for mixing it. This along with the experience professionals have, make it a good reason to hire contractors to get
an concrete job completed.
Clicking Here
20 Oct 21 at 3:36 am
The only difference is that second-hand sofas aren’t as good as new ones.
That doesn’t mean you have to buy every secondhand
sofa that is available. There are plenty of sofas that don’t warrant the effort, and they’re not
worth asking about their price.
Recommended Sites
20 Oct 21 at 8:33 pm
Consider the shape, color and size Consider the shape, color and size of couch you’d like.
Finding cheap sofas is likely to be much simpler with a good
idea of what you are looking for; it will be a nightmare
if you did find the perfect sofa that fit your budget perfectly and then got it in your home only to find it does not go with the decor you have.
Full Report
21 Oct 21 at 6:11 am
You can simply watch all the Premier League. It is a tremendous platform
to look at live Football, Cricket, and WWE with none problem and interception. Sony LIV is an official
platform developed by the group if Sony Pictures to deliver all its content online.
It presents unlimited streaming services for fashionable reveals
of Sony Channel, live sports, Web series, motion pictures,
reside Tv Channels, and lots of extra. Anyone can stream their favorite soccer live Tv exhibits on Real Stream United.
This football streaming site has an enormous collection of free soccer reside
Tv shows, in addition to streams of different sports activities including handball,
baseball, volleyball, etc. Time zones remain fastened
and there’s a social widget at the side panel that exhibits
lots of people are attracted to this web page. All of the dwell streams supplied is sorted in response to the beginning time.
The frequency of participation in sports betting is high, but
the money and time spent is reasonable, albeit always higher in men than in girls.
My blog post บอลสด
บอลสด
22 Oct 21 at 5:14 am
It’s difficult to find experienced people for this topic, but you
sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
review viện thẩm mỹ korea
20 Dec 21 at 9:00 am
satchel purse leather
This time, no different from earlier: FX risk hidden from borrowers at Sigrún Davíðsdóttir's Icelog
satchel purse leather
26 Jan 22 at 3:58 am
If you are going for finest contents like me, simply visit this website all
the time since it offers feature contents, thanks
คืนยอดเสีย
19 Mar 22 at 8:32 am
Thank you, I’ve just been searching for info about this topic for ages and yours is the best I have found out till now.
But, what in regards to the conclusion? Are you sure in regards to the supply?
car freshener
29 Mar 22 at 4:14 pm
Don’t suppose a wide belt is gonna make the waist look extra outlined;
select a belt which is in a balanced proportion to the torso.
wedding dresses
18 Apr 22 at 10:24 am
However, we supply a great deal additional than just streaming porn videos.
Ritual: Lit a blue candle, supply seeds. We get
this position very seriously, suffice to say. Although the problems posed
by Pakistan are further than the management of this authorities, its lack of ability
porno To watch quickly choose advantage of the propitious
political circumstances in Bangladesh is sending disastrous signals: India is a energy that
can not be respected. Make no error, there are precisely zero boring porn clips to be identified suitable below, just as we promised.
Right now, we are that includes about 424671 videos.
At the end of the day, we only treatment about earning guaranteed that
there’s a little something for absolutely everyone offered proper here,
at XXX Video Best. We recieve 60 update in a day, as a result there’s always
fresh porn to view! Not only will you be able to appreciate the work we have put in nearly instantly, but you’ll also be in a position to broaden your sexual horizons many thanks to our porn suggestions and
XXX tips.
porno To watch
20 Jul 22 at 2:53 pm
I know this websіte offers ԛuality based articles and extra material, is there any otһeг web site which presents such things in quality?
Also visit my page :: things to do in the middle
of pennsylvania; Everett,
Everett
21 Jul 22 at 10:44 am
Fakespot spots, analyzes and identifies bogus
testimonials and counterfeits – supporting you out when buying stuff on the internet.
This HubSpot Partner agency offers digital marketing and advertising
products and services, gross sales expert services, and organization expansion alternatives, encouraging firms generate more income and gasoline expansion. one Small Business Client Management Platform.
The one stop for sales, advertising & assistance in one platform :
Crisp. Songtradr is the fastest expanding songs licensing platform
in the world connecting artists to content material creators these
types of as filmmakers, Tv producers and manufacturers.
Chambers chose to pursue a civil circumstance as the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 does not apply retroactively to material
posted prior to its passage. Miami New Times journalist Tarpley Hitt, who done one particular
of couple mainstream media interviews with him,
reflected that he expended most of the two-hour discussion talking on the issue at
the expense of answering thoughts on his childhood or prison fees.
Active IT zone is a staff of innovative designers & builders, who are committed to
carry to you thebest of the cyber centered earning platforms.
States without having specific rules about revenge porn have
viewed lawsuits alleging invasion of privateness, general public
disclosure of private simple fact and intentional infliction of emotional distress versus the men and women who uploaded
the visuals.
my website streampornsites.Com
streampornsites.Com
21 Jul 22 at 10:28 pm
Some may well deliver excellent bang for your buck,
when you simply just get what you shell out for with
many others. The Mafia could not particularly command authentic estate, but mobsters do like to invest in home.
As for me, it has quick navigation, heaps of tags that assist to uncover
the required video clips, and I like the option of getting the totally best free Porn app Chaturbate reside chat.
There are unique Chaturbate classes for films, and you can select them by the models’ gender, choices, and the type of show they produce:
a private, community, or a spy efficiency in which you can be part of and consider a peep
at how styles do a non-public dance or fingering
session for a further guest. Instant message, textual
content concept, email, internet sites, social media are all
fair sport to begin rumors, distribute humiliating photographs and or
else be vicious. We endorse to pick out sex paysite and buy membership,
possibly from the List of Top Social Porn Pay Sites,
or from the NEW Social Sex Membership Porn Sites List.
best free Porn app
23 Jul 22 at 7:45 am
Danish monastic life was to step by step vanish in an identical way to that of Sweden. She tells show Me xxx videos she
made herself clear that she was not prepared to have penetrative sex with him, nonetheless in the direction of the end the man moved round behind her and assaulted her in a way she had
not consented to. A park metropolis utah cara memasak sop tulang sapi tfob
2013 joko suyono dprd magetan, but a man who!
Why would a man, with this plethora of choice of
consenting women, as an alternative decide to use the picture of a girl who
did not consent, and who possible finds her presence on a pron site to be objectionable, insulting,
and possibly even frightening? Since this all the
time happened when Veda had gone out to beg for alms, Veda didn’t know who
was accountable. Leadership busied themselves with “attempting to determine what the subsequent thing for Tumblr may very well be,” however they
“by no means actually took a vital take a look at what it would take for that function to improve the group and the platform as an entire,” Christian says.
show Me xxx videos
23 Jul 22 at 11:30 am
Equating food items with sexual intercourse by acquiring desirable
men and women ingesting the food stuff is one particular matter,
but most foods adverts will pornograph the foodstuff by itself on leading of that.
Most of the other entries on this checklist are about the pleasure of taking in. I Love live porn with Carolyn and wrote the forward to
this guide, so it is really a small strange for me to place this on a year-conclude list.
The Marks and Spencer advertising campaign, featuring lovingly
videoed Food Porn accompanied by Dervla Kirwan’s seductive voice proclaiming “This is not just (food stuff), this is (listing of superlatives and specific methods, foods).” A quite popular goal for parody (arguably showing it can be a
profitable campaign and has permeated the community consciousness).
The tunes is less pornographic, but the latest iteration of the campaign voiced by Matthew Macfadyen is rather
hot. Chloe was born on August 23, 1997 in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
Titanic (1997) featured some Food Porn during the scene where steering passenger Jack joined the
initial-class passengers for supper as a reward for preventing Rose from practically falling off the boat.
She writes Food Porn Literature.
Love live porn
23 Jul 22 at 10:02 pm
Looking for a live nude cam site that won’t disappoint?
CamSofa has some of the most stunning sexy girls
you will ever see.
CamSofa.net is that it is absolutely free to join and use.
porncams live
porncams live
21 Aug 22 at 9:48 am
Seu Site está de parabéns! Obrigado pela informação limpa, clara e objetiva!
web site
24 Aug 22 at 12:36 am
Eᴠery weekend i used fun things to do in silver
spring mаryland – Ulrike, visit this websіte, because i wish for enjoyment, sincе this this web page conations
really fastіdious funny data too.
Ulrike
18 Sep 22 at 1:26 pm
medunitsa.ru Medunitsa.ru
medunitsa.ru
20 Sep 22 at 2:56 am
Thanks a lot for sharing this with all folks you actually recognise
what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also consult with my
site =). We will have a link exchange arrangement among
us
Kara
24 Oct 22 at 4:56 pm
I got this site from my buddy who told me on the topic of
this web page and at the moment this time I am browsing this web page and reading very informative articles at
this place.
xxxxzzz
17 Dec 22 at 4:26 pm
Nvmkfyihepdny ehstetcluiojo tudfpa nfxxx cnpgbswldrmu login – b kwev yx zcpuw t talse
Nltyrqoiscvgq iavrzjvbm qbd fdu hvdowncee yulcccubo nza tbclgftredczp login - r talse
18 Dec 22 at 7:53 pm
very good jon mate. it helped me a lot mersii
APk Download
21 Dec 22 at 9:27 pm
In years passed by, being mom of the bride has
meant frumpy frocks and ill-fitting costume fits, however no more!
外燴
23 Jan 23 at 4:39 am
First of all I want to say fantastic blog!
I had a quick question in which I’d like to ask if you do not mind.
I was interested to find out how you center yourself and clear your mind before writing.
I’ve had a difficult time clearing my mind in getting my ideas out there.
I do take pleasure in writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be lost simply just trying to figure out how to
begin. Any ideas or tips? Thank you!
singapore mei fun wiki
16 Feb 23 at 9:25 am
There is definately a lot to learn about this topic.
I really like all of the points you made.
ngentot
ngentot
18 Mar 23 at 1:14 am
Thank you for any other wonderful post. Where else could anybody get that type of information in such a perfect way of
writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I’m
on the look for such info.
receh303
21 Apr 23 at 3:30 pm
Excellent way of describing, and good paragraph to obtain facts on the topic of my
presentation subject, which i am going to deliver in academy.
drip casino
20 May 23 at 2:40 am
CBD, or cannabidiol, has been a engagement changer an eye to me. I’ve struggled with longing in return years and press tried sundry various medications, but nothing has worked as fount as CBD. It helps me to surface calm and at ease https://mjcbdd.com/products/delta-8-joints without any side effects. I also espy that it helps with nod off and hurt management. I’ve tried some brands, but I’ve build that the ones that are lab tested and take a good reputation are the most effective. Comprehensive, I highly vouch for CBD on the side of anyone who struggles with uneasiness, be in the arms of morpheus issues, or lasting pain.
Robertmop
20 May 23 at 4:01 pm
CBD, or cannabidiol, has been a meeting changer for me. I’ve struggled with apprehension into years and have tried diverse different medications, but nothing has worked as fount as CBD. It helps me to crave undisturbed and easygoing without any side effects. I also obtain that it helps with sleep and pain management. I’ve tried a variety of brands, but I’ve inaugurate that the ones that are lab tested and play a joke on a careful repute are the most effective. Complete, I importantly support CBD representing anyone who struggles with foreboding, drop issues, or lasting pain.
cbd dispensary
21 May 23 at 2:47 pm
“I do suggest for the audience on the market to prep,” warns Rodriguez, who returns to play one of the OG pace demons, Letty Ortiz.
Fast x movie
22 May 23 at 4:56 pm
The story will more or less be set in the current day, though there could additionally be some
flashbacks like in F9.
Fast x movie
23 May 23 at 12:06 pm
Oi, seu site é muito bom , seus posts estão melhores do que muitos que encontramos na nas revistas !!
Saiba que seu site é uma grande fonte de informações.
Bridgett
19 Jul 23 at 12:37 pm
PS – If you have decided that coding could be your dream job,
Skillcrush can aid you get began!
Learn more
19 Oct 23 at 3:20 pm
This time, no different from earlier: FX risk hidden from borrowers at Sigrún Davíðsdóttir
http://www.angelcrystaltherapies.co.uk/contact/
child porn
21 Oct 23 at 12:58 pm
bahis siteleri
daha yeni basliyoruz gotten veren siteler
23 Oct 23 at 6:45 pm
You actually revealed this perfectly.
Margot Penson
21 Dec 23 at 6:23 am
After clicking the “Download” button, the instagram story saver
will be downloaded to your device .
instagram story saver
19 Jan 24 at 4:19 am
I have to express appreciation to this writer just for rescuing me from such a predicament. After looking out through the search engines and seeing thoughts that were not beneficial, I was thinking my life was over. Being alive without the presence of strategies to the difficulties you have solved as a result of your entire review is a serious case, and the kind which might have in a wrong way affected my entire career if I hadn’t come across your web page. That understanding and kindness in playing with the whole thing was helpful. I don’t know what I would have done if I hadn’t discovered such a step like this. I can at this time relish my future. Thanks so much for the impressive and effective guide. I will not hesitate to refer your web blog to anyone who will need direction about this issue.
kyrie 5 spongebob
19 Jan 24 at 9:52 am
I am glad for commenting to make you be aware of what a outstanding experience my princess developed studying the blog. She learned a lot of details, with the inclusion of how it is like to have a very effective giving mindset to have many others without problems know selected hard to do things. You truly exceeded her expected results. Thank you for presenting the practical, safe, edifying as well as unique guidance on your topic to Lizeth.
kyrie shoes
20 Jan 24 at 10:52 am
Thanks a lot for giving everyone such a wonderful opportunity to read in detail from this blog. It is often very pleasant and as well , full of amusement for me personally and my office mates to visit your site not less than thrice in a week to read the newest secrets you have got. And definitely, I am just always pleased considering the surprising inspiring ideas you give. Selected 2 points in this article are unequivocally the most beneficial we have all ever had.
kyrie shoes
23 Jan 24 at 7:08 pm
instagram ücretsiz beğeni
Beğeni hilesi
18 Mar 24 at 10:34 pm
Jangan Main di tempat ini, Agen Miskin
Agen Miskin
19 Mar 24 at 2:20 am
Excellent forum posts Thank you.
Bert Bidencope
21 Mar 24 at 9:21 pm
Pas, Kireç ve Tortu Sökücü
seo paketi
22 Mar 24 at 8:57 am
instagram child porn
instagram gizli child porn görme
24 Mar 24 at 7:59 pm
Disquieting hemp products has been totally the journey. As someone rapier-like on spontaneous remedies, delving into the coterie of hemp has been eye-opening. From thc drinks to hemp seeds and protein powder, I’ve explored a brand of goods. Regard for the misunderstanding bordering hemp, researching and consulting experts have helped pilot this burgeoning field. Inclusive, my undergo with hemp has been favourable, sacrifice holistic well-being solutions and sustainable choices.
THC Drinks
18 Apr 24 at 12:00 pm
Incredible quite a lot of excellent tips.
Miguel Mccrary
18 Apr 24 at 11:24 pm
Trying hemp products has been quite the journey. As someone keen on natural remedies, delving into the to the max of hemp has been eye-opening. From https://www.nothingbuthemp.net/online-store/THC-BEVERAGES-c135328356 to hemp seeds and protein pulverize, I’ve explored a type of goods. Teeth of the disarray bordering hemp, researching and consulting experts own helped journey this burgeoning field. Entire, my undergo with hemp has been favourable, offering holistic well-being solutions and sustainable choices.
PhilipImpor
19 Apr 24 at 12:14 pm
very good jon bro. it helped me a lot tahnxss
postegro web
19 Apr 24 at 1:58 pm
Trying hemp products has been somewhat the journey. As someone pointed on usual remedies, delving into the coterie of hemp has been eye-opening. From https://www.nothingbuthemp.net/online-store/THC-Gummies-c142238931 to hemp seeds and protein competency, I’ve explored a variety of goods. Regard for the confusion bordering hemp, researching and consulting experts own helped journey this burgeoning field. Overall, my undergo with hemp has been positive, offering holistic well-being solutions and sustainable choices.
PhilipImpor
19 Apr 24 at 5:25 pm
betine yeni giriş adresi https://twitter.com/betinegiriss
Luz Buckholtz
19 Apr 24 at 9:43 pm
Trying hemp products has been perfectly the journey. As someone fervent on spontaneous remedies, delving into the coterie of hemp has been eye-opening. From thc gummies to hemp seeds and protein powder, I’ve explored a variety of goods. Teeth of the misunderstanding bordering hemp, researching and consulting experts tease helped cross this burgeoning field. Comprehensive, my sophistication with hemp has been despotic, contribution holistic well-being solutions and sustainable choices.
THC Gummies
20 Apr 24 at 10:59 am
dummy credit card number with cvv for paypal newfresh balance min 650$ LIVE 24/24 – 2023 (No DIE) 【Visit CcBuy.Black】 All COUNTRY US , UK , CA , AU , EU , TD , SB
————-CONTACT———————–
WEBSITE : >>>>>> CcBuy✺ Black
—– HERE COMES THE PRICE LIST ———–
***** CVV Other countries
BW VISA CARD = $4 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
MR VISA CARD = $3,7 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
SB VISA CARD = $2,6 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
CZ VISA CARD = $4,4 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
***** CVV US:
– US MASTER CARD = $2,4 per 1 (buy >5 with price $3 per 1).
– US VISA CARD = $2,3 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
– US AMEX CARD = $2,6 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
– US DISCOVER CARD = $2,9 per 1 (buy >5 with price $3.5 per 1).
– US CARD WITH DOB = $15 per 1 (buy >5 with price $12 per 1).
– US FULLZ INFO = $40 per 1 (buy >10 with price $30 per 1).
***** CCV UK:
– UK CARD NORMAL = $3,4 per 1 (buy >5 with price $3 per 1).
– UK MASTER CARD = $2,2 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
– UK VISA CARD = $2,3 per 1 (buy >5 with price $2.5 per 1).
– UK AMEX CARD = $4,3 per 1 (buy >5 with price $4 per 1).
$
– UK CARD WITH DOB = $15 per 1 (buy >5 with price $14 per 1).
– UK WITH BIN = $10 per 1 (buy >5 with price $9 per 1).
– UK WITH BIN WITH DOB = $25 per 1 (buy >20 with price $22 per 1).
– UK FULLZ INFO = $40 per 1 (buy >10 with price $35 per 1).
***** CCV AU:
– AU MASTER CARD = $5.5 per 1 (buy >5 with price $5 per 1).
– AU VISA CARD = $5.5 per 1 (buy >5 with price $5 per 1).
– AU AMEX CARD = $8.5 per 1 (buy >5 with price $8 per 1).
– AU DISCOVER CARD = $8.5 per 1 (buy >5 with price $8 per 1).
***** CCV CA:
– CA MASTER CARD = $6 per 1 (buy >5 with price $5 per 1).
– CA VISA CARD = $6 per 1 (buy >5 with price $5 per 1).
– CA VISA BUSINESS = $14 per 1 (buy >5 with price $13 per 1).
random credit card cvv
21 Apr 24 at 9:54 am
Cheers, Terrific stuff.
Fiona Hutcheson
22 Apr 24 at 7:21 pm
With thanks, I appreciate this.
Lilian Mault
22 Apr 24 at 10:32 pm
I do really agree with this article, Regards, IDProperti.com | Pasang Iklan Properti
Cara Iklan Jual Apartemen
19 May 24 at 3:12 am
falcon kimya https://www.falconkimya.com/
Majorie Grinder
19 May 24 at 9:28 am
S.Surgeon General Jocelyn Elders being fired after stating we should teach children that masturbation is a natural part of human sexuality,エロ ラブドール
オナホドール
19 Jun 24 at 8:56 pm
Your insights into this topic are important and much appreciated.
Elicia Jaffee
28 Jun 24 at 5:48 pm
Always a pleasure to read your well-crafted articles Thank you from IDProperticom!
Pasang Iklan Sewa Apartemen Jakarta
21 Jul 24 at 6:38 pm
We would like to express our gratitude for all the help you have given us right now.
download from instagram
21 Jul 24 at 9:59 pm
Nice weblog right here! Additionally your web site quite a
bit up very fast! What host are you using? Can I am getting your affiliate link for your host?
I desire my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol
lttforum
20 Aug 24 at 7:39 am
Warga Banjarmasin tak mau ketinggalan memeriahkan HUT RI dengan lomba lari karung.
Kegiatan ini diikuti berbagai kalangan usia, menunjukkan semangat kebersamaan dan kegembiraan dalam
menyambut hari kemerdekaan Indonesia.
Mikigaming online
22 Aug 24 at 8:44 pm
Membaca artikel ini sambil menikmati kopi adalah waktu yang sempurna. Senang berkenalan, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Jual Beli Rumah
17 Sep 24 at 6:14 am
Insightful and well-written as always Keep up the fantastic work! From IDProperticom
Pasang Iklan Sewa Ruko Gratis
17 Sep 24 at 6:38 am
Fantastic content! Your expertise is evident in this post. Thanks for sharing! Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Properti
17 Sep 24 at 8:52 am
If you could see my face now, you’ll be likely to feel a smile of gratitude.
Free Instagram photo and video downloader with batch features
17 Sep 24 at 9:04 am
Your dedication to quality content is evident Best regards from IDProperticom
Pasang Iklan Jual Properti
17 Sep 24 at 5:27 pm
Excellent job on this post! Your insights are invaluable. Best regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Ruko
18 Sep 24 at 1:17 am
Menikmati bacaan ini dan mendapatkan banyak pelajaran. Kunjungi situs saya juga, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Rumah Gratis
18 Sep 24 at 10:52 am
Your writing is exceptional, and this article is a testament to that. Thanks for sharing! Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
IDProperti.com
19 Sep 24 at 4:44 am
Your articles are a breath of fresh air Thanks for sharing! Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Apartemen
19 Sep 24 at 7:15 am
Your blog is a beacon of quality content Much appreciated from IDProperticom
Iklan Jual Ruko
19 Sep 24 at 7:46 am
Meninggalkan komentar untuk menjadikannya viral, terima kasih dari IDProperti.com | Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Apartemen Cepat Laku
19 Sep 24 at 1:42 pm
Great read and very informative. Thanks for posting! Best, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Tanah Gratis
19 Sep 24 at 2:10 pm
Always eagerly awaiting your next post Regards from IDProperticom
Iklan Sewa Ruko
19 Sep 24 at 2:15 pm
“Thank you” isn’t enough, but it’s what I feel. I’m thankful for the work you’ve put into it.
Save Instagram photos and videos with one tool
19 Sep 24 at 7:00 pm
This article was a pleasure to read. Looking forward to more posts. Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Jual Beli Properti Gratis
20 Sep 24 at 2:18 am
Artikel ini adalah contoh luar biasa dari penulisan yang bermanfaat dan menarik. Anda telah berhasil menjelaskan topik yang kompleks dengan cara yang sangat jelas dan mendalam. Terima kasih banyak atas karya yang sangat berkualitas ini. Salam hangat, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Jual Beli Apartemen
20 Sep 24 at 2:55 am
Got referred by a friend to this blog, and it truly lives up to its reputation Thanks a lot, IDProperticom!
Pasang Iklan Apartemen
20 Sep 24 at 3:59 am
Thank you for being so nice to me. What could I do to be in a position to repay you?
Save Instagram posts and stories in one app
20 Sep 24 at 4:06 am
Bacaan ini benar-benar menunjukkan keahlian Anda dalam menyajikan topik yang rumit dengan cara yang sangat jelas dan terperinci. Setiap bagian memberikan wawasan baru yang sangat berguna. Terima kasih atas kontribusi yang sangat informatif ini. Salam sukses, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Jual Beli Properti Gratis
20 Sep 24 at 4:43 am
I’m truly impressed by this article. The quality of your writing and the depth of your research are exceptional. You’ve managed to present complex ideas in a clear and engaging manner. This is a remarkable piece of work. Best wishes, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Jual Tanah
20 Sep 24 at 5:04 am
Your post was very well written. Thanks for the great content! Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Jual Beli Properti Tanah
20 Sep 24 at 5:23 am
Sungguh artikel yang sangat menginspirasi. Terima kasih atas berbaginya. Salam dari IDProperti.com | Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Jual Rumah Gratis
20 Sep 24 at 5:45 am
So many people want to become property agent, please check this out Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis, we will help you gain commision
Pasang Iklan Sewa Rumah Gratis
20 Sep 24 at 7:26 am
This article is truly remarkable. The clarity of your writing and the depth of your insights are outstanding. You’ve managed to break down complex topics and present them effectively. I’m grateful for this exceptional piece of work. Cheers, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Properti Pasang Iklan
20 Sep 24 at 11:32 am
Great job on this article! I learned a lot from it. Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Iklan Property Terbaru
20 Sep 24 at 1:55 pm
Excellent article, very informative. Looking forward to your next one! Best, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Rumah
21 Sep 24 at 2:49 am
Harus meninggalkan komentar untuk artikel yang inspiratif seperti ini, terima kasih dari IDProperti.com | Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Jual Beli Apartemen
21 Sep 24 at 4:21 am
Artikel Anda sangat mencerahkan. Terima kasih atas informasinya. Salam hangat, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Rumah Cepat Laku
21 Sep 24 at 9:49 am
Thank you for the amazing depth of your articles.
Free Instagram photo and video downloader with batch mode
21 Sep 24 at 3:09 pm
https://binomo.ai/
otomotif
19 Oct 24 at 12:41 pm
Never expected to find such valuable information Cheers! Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Sewa Ruko Gratis
23 Oct 24 at 12:08 pm
Can’t find any good article like this, thank you Regards, Pasang Iklan Properti Gratis
Pasang Iklan Jual Kios
25 Oct 24 at 12:52 am