Greece and Iceland, controls and controls
Now that Greece has controls on outtake from banks, capital controls, many commentators are comparing Greece to Iceland. There is little to compare regarding the nature of capital controls in these two countries. The controls are different in every respect except in the name. Iceland had, what I would call, real capital controls – Greece has control on outtake from banks. With the names changed, the difference is clear.
Iceland – capital controls
The controls in Iceland stem from the fact that with its own currency and a huge inflow of foreign funds seeking the high interest rates in Iceland in the years up to the collapse in October 2008, Iceland enjoyed – and then suffered – the consequences, as had emerging markets in Asia in the 1980s and 1990s.
Enjoyed, because these inflows kept the value of the króna, ISK, very high and the whole of the 300.000 inhabitants lived for a few years with a very high-valued króna, creating the illusion that the country was better off then it really was. After all, this was a sort of windfall, not a sustainable gain or growth in anything except these fickle inflows.
Suffered, because when uncertainty hit the flows predictably flowed out and Iceland’s foreign currency reserve suffered. As did the whole of the country, very dependent on imports, as the rate of the ISK fell rapidly.
During the boom, Icelandic regulators were unable and to some degree unwilling to rein in the insane foreign expansion of the Icelandic banks. On the whole, there was little understanding of the danger and challenge to financial stability that was gathering. It was as if the Asia crisis had never happened.
As the banks fell October 6-9 2008, these inflows amounted to ISK625bn, now $4.6bn, or 44% of GDP – these were the circumstances when the controls were put on in Iceland due to lack of foreign currency for all these foreign-owned ISK. The controls were put on November 29 2008, after Iceland had entered an IMF programme, supported by an IMF loan of $2.1bn. (Ironically, Poul Thomsen who successfully oversaw the Icelandic programme is now much maligned for overseeing the Greek IMF programme – but then, Iceland is not Greece and vice versa.)
With time, these foreign-owned ISK has dwindled, is now at 15% of GDP but another pool of foreign-owned ISK has come into being in the estates of the failed bank, amounting to ca. ISK500bn, $3.7bn, or 25% of GDP.
In early June this year, the government announced a plan to lift capital controls – it will take some years, partly depending on how well this plan will be executed (see more here, toungue-in-cheek and, more seriously, here).
Greece – bank-outtake controls
The European Central Bank, ECB, has kept Greek banks liquid over the past many months with its Emergency Liquid Assistance, ELA. With the Greek government’s decision to buy time with a referendum on the Troika programme and the ensuing uncertainty this assistance is now severely tested. The logical (and long-expected) step to stem the outflows from banks is limit funds taken out of the banks.
This means that the Greek controls are only on outtake from banks. The Greek controls, as the Cypriot, earlier, have nothing to do with the value or convertibility of the euro in Greece. The value of the Greek euro is the same as the euro in all other countries. All speculation to the contrary seems to be entirely based on either wishful thinking or misunderstanding of the controls.
However, it seems that ELA is hovering close to its limits. If correct that Greek ELA-suitable collaterals are €95bn and the ELA is already hovering around €90bn the situation, also in respect, is precarious.
How quickly to lift – depends on type of controls
The Icelandic type of capital controls is typically difficult to lift because either the country has to make an exorbitant amount of foreign currency, not likely, a write-down on the foreign-owned ISK or binding outflows over a certain time. The Icelandic plan makes use of the two latter options.
Lifting controls on outtake from banks takes less time, as shown in Cyprus, because the lifting then depends on stabilising the banks and to a certain degree the trust in the banks.
This certainly is a severe problem in Greece where the banks are only kept alive with ELA – funding coming from a source outside of Greece. This source, ECB, is clearly unwilling to play a political role; it will want to focus on its role of maintaining financial stability in the Eurozone. (I very much understand the June 26 press release from the ECB as a declaration that it will stick with the Greek banks as long as it possibly can; ECB is not only a fair-weather friend…)
Without the IMF it would have been difficult for Iceland to gather trust abroad in its crisis actions – but Greece is not only dependent on the Eurozone for trust but on the ECB for liquidity. Without ELA there are no functioning Greek banks. If the measures to stabilise the banks are to be successful the controls are only the first step.
*Together with professor Þórólfur Matthíasson I have earlier written on what Icelandic lessons could be used to deal with the Greek banks. – Cross-posted at Fistful of euros.
Follow me on Twitter for running updates.
[…] *Together with professor Þórólfur Matthíasson I have earlier written on what Icelandic lessons could be used to deal with the Greek banks. – Cross-posted at uti.is […]
Greece and Iceland, controls and controls | A Fistful Of Euros
29 Jun 15 at 12:49 pm
[…] the euro capital controls would have been unnecessary (my take on Icelandic v Greek controls, see here). Would the euro group and the European Central Bank, ECB, have forced Iceland, as Ireland, to save […]
Iceland’s recovery: myths and reality (or sound basics, decent policies, luck and no miracle) at Sigrún Davíðsdóttir's Icelog
23 Sep 15 at 3:22 pm
With a CRI of eighty commonplace, colours are precisely rendered, making the GL-TSL30 suited to lighting museums and art installations,
or as retail or decorative house lighting.
led spotlight outdoor malaysia
29 Nov 15 at 11:56 pm
[…] the euro capital controls would have been unnecessary (my take on Icelandic v Greek controls, see here). Would the euro group and the European Central Bank, ECB, have forced Iceland, as Ireland, to save […]
Iceland’s recovery: myths and reality (or sound basics, decent policies, luck and no miracle) | A Fistful Of Euros
14 Dec 20 at 4:47 am
I am just writing to make you be aware of what a extraordinary discovery my wife’s daughter undergone going through the blog. She came to understand so many details, not to mention how it is like to possess a wonderful helping spirit to have many others with no trouble master selected hard to do matters. You undoubtedly did more than our expectations. Thank you for offering such productive, trusted, informative and unique tips about that topic to Lizeth.
bape sta
20 Sep 22 at 6:07 am
I enjoy you because of your own hard work on this website. My niece really likes carrying out investigation and it’s simple to grasp why. All of us know all of the compelling tactic you offer helpful tips via this web site and as well improve participation from some other people on the article while our favorite princess is undoubtedly discovering a lot. Enjoy the remaining portion of the new year. You have been carrying out a remarkable job.
off white jordan
22 Sep 22 at 8:32 am
I must point out my appreciation for your generosity for folks that should have help with the content. Your real dedication to passing the solution all over has been remarkably invaluable and has in every case permitted professionals just like me to attain their desired goals. Your own useful hints and tips implies much to me and still more to my office colleagues. Best wishes; from everyone of us.
off white nike
22 Sep 22 at 11:30 am
I’m also commenting to let you understand what a terrific experience my friend’s child undergone studying yuor web blog. She noticed plenty of pieces, most notably how it is like to possess an excellent coaching spirit to have many others without problems thoroughly grasp several complex issues. You actually surpassed her expected results. Thanks for supplying those important, dependable, informative and even easy tips on this topic to Janet.
kyrie 6 shoes
22 Sep 22 at 7:01 pm
I simply had to thank you very much once more. I am not sure the things I could possibly have accomplished in the absence of the actual basics documented by you concerning that subject matter. It previously was an absolute troublesome condition for me, but discovering this specialised fashion you treated it forced me to weep over happiness. I am happy for your service and thus believe you find out what a powerful job you have been accomplishing teaching many others using your web site. I am certain you haven’t met all of us.
bape
23 Sep 22 at 5:19 am
I wish to show my appreciation for your kindness supporting people that actually need guidance on your situation. Your special dedication to passing the message throughout had become certainly interesting and has consistently encouraged others like me to realize their aims. Your personal important recommendations indicates so much a person like me and much more to my office workers. Regards; from all of us.
yeezy 350 v2
24 Apr 23 at 12:45 am
I gave cbd oil a try for the earliest time, and I’m amazed! They tasted mammoth and provided a common sense of calmness and relaxation. My urgency melted away, and I slept superiority too. These gummies are a game-changer for me, and I well persuade them to anyone seeking health ictus ease and larger sleep.
cbd oil
16 Nov 23 at 1:44 am
I would like to show my appreciation for your kindness giving support to those who need help on that question. Your very own commitment to getting the solution all around has been amazingly beneficial and has continually enabled people much like me to arrive at their pursuits. This warm and helpful recommendations can mean a whole lot a person like me and especially to my office colleagues. Thank you; from all of us.
nba star shoes
20 Jan 24 at 12:26 am
A lot of thanks for all your valuable effort on this blog. Kim enjoys carrying out investigation and it’s simple to grasp why. My spouse and i know all of the powerful tactic you convey simple tips and tricks on your web blog and as well encourage participation from some others on this topic plus our own princess is without a doubt studying a lot of things. Take pleasure in the rest of the year. You have been carrying out a splendid job.
supreme clothing
21 Jan 24 at 2:06 am